1985 1987 - Jerome Henderson, West Palm Beach Stingrays
- Tom Collier, Long Island Knights
- Leroy Combs, Rhode Island Gulls
- Muggsy Bogues, Rhode Island Gulls
- Clinton Wheeler, Miami Tropics
1991 1993 - Darrell Armstrong, Atlanta Eagles
- Fred Lewis, Daytona Beach Hooters
- Khari Jaxon, Palm Beach Stingrays
- Lamont Middleton, Long Island Surf
- Antonio Harvey, Atlanta Eagles
1995 - Charles Smith, Florida Sharks
- Charles Thomas, Jersey Turnpikes
- Kevin Salvadori, Florida Sharks
- Godfrey Thompson, Connecticut Skyhawks
- Mark Boyd, Florida Sharks
1997 - LaMark Baker, Atlantic City Seagulls
- Jerry McCullough, New Hampshire Thunder Loons
- Mikki Moore, Atlanta Trojans
- Jay Webb, Portland Wave
- Tim Moore, Jacksonville Barracudas
1999 - Gerald Walker, Kansas Cagerz
- Adrian Griffin, Atlantic City Seagulls
- Godfrey Thompson, Connecticut Skyhawks
- Johnny Tyson, Gulf Coast SunDogs
- Omm'A Givens, New Jersey Shorecats
- Garth Joseph, Atlantic City Seagulls
2001 - Charles Macon, Atlantic City Seagulls
- Johnny Jackson, Kansas Cagerz
- Dominick Young, Kansas Cagerz
- Johnny Tyson, Oklahoma Storm
- Tim Winn, Pennsylvania ValleyDawgs
2003 - Kareem Reid, Pennsylvania ValleyDawgs
- Tim Winn, Pennsylvania ValleyDawgs
- Immanuel McElroy, Dodge City Legend
- Kevin Freeman, Westchester Wildfire
- Johnny Jackson, Kansas Cagerz
2005 - Badou Gaye, Westchester Wildfire
- Anthony Glover, Brooklyn Kings
- Jeremee McGuire, Kansas Cagerz
- Eric Coley, Oklahoma Storm
- Kyle Williams, Brooklyn Kings
2007 | 1986 - Jerome Henderson, Springfield Fame
- Jim Lampley, Wildwood Aces
- Hot Rod Williams, Staten Island Stallions
- Michael Adams, Springfield Fame
- James Carter, Staten Island Stallions
1988 - Herbert Blunt, Long Island Knights
- Michael Brooks, Philadelphia Aces
- Bobby Parks, New Haven Skyhawks
- Avery Johnson, Palm Beach Stingrays
- Andre Turner, Miami Tropics
1990 - Alex Roberts, New York Whitecaps
- Norris Coleman, Jacksonville Hooters
- Gary Massey, New Haven Skyhawks
- Jerry Johnson, Jacksonville Hooters
- Howard Evans, Philadelphia Aces
1992 1994 - Darrell Armstrong, Atlanta Trojans
- Dave Whitney, Mississippi Coast Gamblers
- Keith Lee, Memphis Fire
- Mark Strickland, Atlanta Trojans
- Godfrey Thompson, Connecticut Skyhawks
1996 - Greg Grant, Atlantic City Seagulls
- Charles Smith, Florida Sharks
- Mark Strickland, Atlantic City Seagulls
- Joe Hooks, Connecticut Skyhawks
- Corey Williams, Long Island Surf
1998 - Mike Lloyd, Atlantic City Seagulls
- Curt Smith, Washington Congressionals
- Shane Drisdon, Connecticut Skyhawks
- Art Long, Jacksonville Barracudas
- Andre Perry, Atlanta Trojans
2000 - Alvin Jefferson, Dodge City Legend
- Ace Custis, Pennsylvania ValleyDawgs
- LaMarr Greer, Atlantic City Seagulls
- Mark Blount, New Jersey Shorecats
- Darrin Hancock, Dodge City Legend
2002 - Fred House, Adirondack Wildcats
- Ronnie Fields, Pennsylvania ValleyDawgs
- Ira Clark, Oklahoma Storm
- Johnny Jackson, Kansas Cagerz
- Simeon Haley, Brevard Blue Ducks
2004 - Tyson Patterson, Florence Flyers
- Immanuel McElroy, Dodge City Legend
- Tim Winn, Pennsylvania ValleyDawgs
- B.J. McFarlan, Brooklyn Kings
- Lonnie Jones, Oklahoma Storm
2006 - Kyle Williams, Brooklyn Kings
- Anthony Johnson, Kansas Cagerz
- Roberto Gittens, Long Island PrimeTime
- Darrell Johns, Kansas Cagerz
- John Thomas, Long Island PrimeTime
|